The Top Flavored Whiskeys Our Guests Love

Flavored whiskeys are flying off our shelves, and for good reason! These unique, high-quality options from top brands are the new craze in the whiskey world. So, we’re sharing our top guest-favorite flavored whiskeys that are worth sipping.

Flavored whiskey is made essentially the same way as traditional whiskey, except a flavor element is infused either during or after distillation.¹ Flavored whiskeys simply add an additional flavoring component that plays well with the natural flavor profile of the spirit, like fruit, honey, nuts or something completely novel, like cookie dough. Even whiskey purists are starting to add bottles of flavored whiskey to their bar carts for a hint of variety.

Just like a traditional whiskey, flavored whiskey can be sipped straight or mixed into a cocktail. Sipping it straight will allow the full flavor profile of the whiskey to take center stage so you can analyze how the flavor infusion interacts with the raw whiskey in more detail. Some mixologists love using flavored spirits because it cuts out the extra step of adding a separate element for flavor, like simple syrups, shrubs or bitters.

With so many flavored whiskey options hitting shelves, it can be difficult to pick one you like enough that’s worth the price of a full bottle. Thankfully, ABC offers free sampling in all stores AND has awesome guests who are all too willing to share their thoughts on their favorite flavored whiskeys. Keep reading for our nine top-selling flavored whiskeys that guests rave about and the signature cocktails you should try them in.

We’re starting off strong with the king (no pun intended) of flavored whiskeys, Crown Royal. This limited time* blackberry flavored Canadian whisky harmoniously blends the flavors of dark summer fruit with the signature richness of Crown that we all know and love. If you find it on our shelves, you better grab a bottle because this whisky sells out fast.

If you enjoy Jameson’s classic smooth, slightly sweet and spicy flavor profile, Jameson Orange’s addition of zesty citrus is just the bottle for you. It’s delicate and smooth while adding a juicy hit of orange and signature punch of Jameson spice on the finish.

ABC guest Black Barbie said in their 5-star review on our site that it’s “amazing paired with Sprite.” This may be our go-to summer cool-down cocktail, along with this one:

Skrewball is a true OG of the flavored whiskey space with their iconic peanut butter flavored whiskey. If you’re reaching the bottom of your bottle of Skrewball, check out Blind Squirrel Peanut Butter Whiskey to expand your PB whiskey repertoire. Plus, with spinoff flavors like peanut butter banana, peanut butter and jelly, and peanut butter chocolate pretzel, the whiskey options from Blind Squirrel are endless.

ABC guest Luh Grimes said they “already bought 3 bottles and can’t wait to buy another one” in their 5-star review of Blind Squirrel Peanut Butter Whiskey on our site.

A continuous guest favorite, Cooper’s Mark Honey Bourbon has mouthwatering aromas of vanilla bean, dried cherry and honey gelato with a sweet, medium body. Like any flavored whiskey worth its salt, it’s equally delicious mixed in a cocktail or sipped neat.

“Tried this honey bourbon at a tasting/promo table and was so impressed I bought a bottle that day and have been buying it since. I’m a regular bourbon drinker and have never tried a flavored style. Gotta tell ya Cooper’s Mark is a definite keeper. Best when served over ice.” - Guest Aloysius McCloud

‘Tis the season for peach tea, and the results are in: guests say this is the best peach whiskey to mix into your pitcher of Southern sweet tea this summer. The 5-star guest reviews across the board on our site don’t lie; keep this one stocked in your home bar all summer long for peachy keen cocktails and tipples.

The unique flavor of this whiskey may make you scratch your head at first, but trust our guests: this one makes believers out of non-whiskey drinkers and seasoned whiskey connoisseurs alike. We’ll let this review of the world’s first whipped cream whiskey do the talking:

“I'm a big whiskey drinker who typically doesn't go for anything with a sweet flavor, but Whiplash has changed my mind on that,” user SomeRandomBostonian said in their 5-star review on our site. “Whiplash has a wonderful, full body flavor with a wonderful punch of vanilla right at the end. On top of the fantastic flavor profile, this whiskey has just the right amount of burn right on the finish, which reminds you that while delicious, this is still a serious spirit. I highly recommend Whiplash for experienced whiskey drinkers and novices alike.”

What would a flavored whiskey round-up be without a bottle of Jack? Jack Daniel’s Tennessee Apple Whiskey blends the bright flavor of freshly cut apples with warm caramel and toffee that balances that classic Jack spice.

“It was exactly what I was looking for when I found it. Something with a good amount of apple flavor but didn't let go of its roots in the process,” ABC guest s2clean said in their 5-star review on our website. “Highly recommend if you are looking for something with a little extra flavor.”

If Scotch feels stuffy, unapproachable and only for grandpas, allow us to introduce you to your new favorite bottle. Buchanan’s Pineapple Scotch blends the sophisticated structure of good Scotch with flavors of luscious, juicy pineapple and a hint of zesty citrus. It’s perfect for adding a hint of depth to your fruity, fizzy summer cocktails.

“I really wasn’t sure what to expect. I used to drink bourbon, but generally shy away from ‘flavored’ spirits in general,” ABC guest jessicam1705 said in their 5-star review on our site. “What a pleasant surprise how delish this is! I tried it over ice first and yum…then I added some Hal’s mango seltzer and PERFECTION!!!”

Dough Dough Bird Whiskey burst onto the flavored spirits scene in 2022 with their cookie dough whiskey to mixed reactions of shock and awe. But, as with any good spirit, the contents of the bottle did the talking and whiskey drinkers were hooked from the first sip. Now, they’ve done it again with Dough Dough Bird Churro Whiskey, a whiskey sweetened with a cinnamon sugar and spice combo that tastes just like the iconic fried treat.

“I've had Dough Dough Bird Cookie Dough Whiskey and loved the flavor, so I was excited to try this one. It tastes exactly like a churro! I will 100% buy it again,” said ABC user Ben95 in their 5-star review on our site.